What is the best way to catch a starling with your American Kestrel?

Catching a starling with an American Kestrel is best achieved from close range while they are bathing. This is because starlings are often distracted and less alert during bathing, making them easier targets for a raptor. The proximity increases the chances of a successful strike, as the kestrel can quickly swoop in before the starling has a chance to react or take flight.

In contrast, waiting from a high perch might allow for a broader visibility but may not produce a quick attack opportunity, especially if the starlings are not in the vicinity. The ringing flight technique refers to the idea of calling or enticing prey, which may not be as effective as taking advantage of the bird's vulnerability while it is occupied with bathing. The notion that it is "not possible" overlooks the specific circumstances under which hunting can successfully occur, particularly when prey is in a state of distraction. Thus, the close-range approach during bathing provides the best scenario for the American Kestrel to catch a starling.